The Vault

Over the years, we've made SO. MANY. FLAVORS. While we can't keep them all in stock all at once, some of them do come back each season. You can find ones that are semi-retired on this page.

Our VIPs get exclusive access to some of these flavors in the Team Treat Yourself Lounge.

Want in? Join Team Treat Yourself here!

Subscribe to our newsletter to be notified if any return!

Apple Crisp
Blueberry Crisp
NEW!
Blueberry Muffin
Café Frappé
Caramel Corn
Caramel Cupcake
Cherry Cheesecake
Cherry Cola Float
Cherry Mint Milkshake
Chocolate Banana Bread
Chocolate Macaroon
Chocolate Orange
Chocolate Raspberry
Chocolate Strawberry
Cinnamon Bun
Cinnamon Kettle Corn
Cinnamon Latte
Exfoliating Lip Balm - Apple Crisp
Exfoliating Lip Balm - Raspberry Lemonade
Exfoliating Lip Balm - Strawberry Lemon Sorbet
Exfoliating Lip Balm - Strawberry Sundae
Exfoliating Lip Balm - Watermelon Gelato
Funnel Cake
Gingerbread Latte
Gingerbread Mocha
Key Lime Pie
Mojito Sorbet
Orange Cream Sorbet
Peach Pie
Peanut Butter and Jelly
Peanut Butter Chocolate
Pear Crisp
Pink Grapefruit Sorbet
Raspberry Latte
Raspberry Lemonade
Raspberry Sorbet
NEW!
Root Beer Float
Spiced Cherry Cookie
Strawberry Lemon Sorbet
Strawberry Sundae
Vanilla Crispy Treat
Vanilla Latte
Watermelon Gelato
White Chocolate Fudge